Introduction

Process safety management (PSM) is a critical framework that safeguards industrial operations, protecting lives, the environment, and valuable assets. It encompasses a comprehensive set of practices and guidelines to identify, understand, and manage the risks associated with chemical processes and equipment in industries such as oil and gas, chemical manufacturing, and pharmaceuticals.

In this article, I will delve into the importance of PSM, its key elements, and how organizations can implement and enhance their process safety management systems.

The Significance of Process Safety Management

In industrial environments, process safety is of paramount importance. It ensures that operations involving hazardous materials are conducted in a manner that minimizes the risk of accidents, releases, and incidents. The significance of PSM can be summarized as follows:

  1. Human Safety: The primary objective of PSM is to protect the safety and well-being of workers, nearby communities, and the general public. Ensuring that processes and equipment are operated safely reduces the likelihood of accidents, injuries, and fatalities.
  2. Environmental Protection: PSM also plays a crucial role in preventing environmental disasters, such as chemical spills, leaks, or emissions that could harm ecosystems and natural resources.
  3. Asset Protection: Process safety management safeguards valuable assets, including equipment, facilities, and the company’s reputation. By minimizing incidents, it helps avoid costly damage and downtime.

Key Elements of Process Safety Management (PSM)

Effective process safety management involves a combination of key elements designed to identify, assess, and mitigate risks.
There are two guidelines that are frequently referred to and used for implementing a PSM system:

  1. OSHA
  2. CCPS risk-based approach

Both approaches are grounded in four key foundational pillars, often referred to as the foundational blocks or pillars. Each of these pillars encompasses several crucial elements, serving as integral topics to meticulously monitor.

This ensures that safety within a business is thoroughly considered, consistently maintained, diligently followed up, documented and those documents are regularly updated.
The foundation pillars are:

  1. Commitment to process safety.
  2. Understanding hazards and risk.
  3. Managing the risk.
  4. Learning from experience.

Note that terminology in literature may vary, but the underlying concept behind the naming remains consistent.

The number of elements varies depending on the approach:

  1. The OSHA approach consists of 14 elements.
  2. The CCPS risk-based approach includes 20 elements.

The OSHA approach:

The OSHA approach has 14 elements, commonly known as the “14 elements”, include the following:

  1. Process Safety Information: Gathering and maintaining data on equipment, materials, and processes is fundamental to understanding the potential hazards.
  2. Process Hazard Analysis: Identifying and assessing potential hazards and their potential consequences, including conducting risk assessments.
  3. Operating Procedures: Developing and maintaining clear and comprehensive operating procedures to ensure safe and consistent operations.
  4. Training and Competency: Ensuring that personnel are adequately trained and competent to perform their roles safely and effectively.
  5. Mechanical Integrity: Implementing a program to maintain equipment integrity, including inspections and maintenance routines.
  6. Management of Change: Evaluating and managing any changes to processes, equipment, or materials to avoid unintended consequences.
  7. Pre-Startup Safety Review: Conducting safety reviews before starting up or modifying processes.
  8. Emergency Planning and Response: Developing plans and procedures to respond to emergencies and mitigate their impact.
  9. Compliance Audits: Regularly conducting audits and inspections to ensure ongoing compliance and identify potential issues. Adhering to industry standards and regulations related to process safety.
  10. Hot work permit: This system is designed to document and monitor necessary maintenance tasks for the smooth operation of the plant. It ensures a comprehensive examination of job-related risks, promotes awareness among maintenance personnel carrying the job, and implements measures to mitigate and combat hazards, such as fire. Additionally, it guarantees that maintenance activities are conducted without disrupting live plant operations, preventing the creation of potentially dangerous situations.
  11. Incident Investigation: Investigating and analysing incidents to prevent their recurrence.
  12. Trade secrets: Ensuring the confidentiality of process safety information classified as a trade secret is imperative. Various strategies can be employed to safeguard trade secrets, encompassing physical security measures, electronic safeguards, and the implementation of non-disclosure agreements.
  13. Employee Participation: Encouraging and involving employees in the PSM process, as they are often the first to identify potential issues.
  14. Contractor Management: Managing and assessing the safety performance of contractors who work on-site.

This approach is visually depicted through a graphic representation, illustrated as follows:

Process Safety Management OSHA approach

The CCPS risk-based approach:

The CCPS approach has 20 elements, commonly known as the “Risk based PSM – CCPS approach”, include the following:

  1. Process safety Culture
  2. Standards, code, regulations and laws
  3. Process safety competency
  4. Workforce involvement
  5. Stakeholder outreach
  6. Process knowledge management
  7. Hazard identification and risk analysis
  8. Operating procedure
  9. Safe work practices
  10. Asset integrity and reliability
  11. Contractor management
  12. Training and performance assurance
  13. Management of change
  14. Operational readiness
  15. Conduct of operations
  16. Emergency management
  17. Incident investigation
  18. Measurement and metrics
  19. Auditing
  20. Management review and continuous improvement

This approach is visually depicted through a graphic representation, illustrated as follows:

Process Safety Management CCPS risk-based approach

Comparison between the two approaches:

A comparison between the two approachs reveals that the CCPS approach is more comprehensive, encompassing an additional six elements compared to the OSHA approach:

  1. Process safety culture
    Process safety culture is defined as the amalgamation of collective values and behaviours that are essential to the management of process safety, basically they are: way of working, responsibility of employees towards safety and reporting and investigating the incidents. This means that management has a big role in establishing a good safety culture and maintaining it by leading as an example.
  2. Process safety competency
    This element promotes the collection and dissemination of information, along with ongoing training in the realm of process safety. The aim is to ensure the competency of individuals, keeping their knowledge, and consequently, the organization’s knowledge, current.
  3. Stakeholder outreach
    Stakeholder outreach involves exchanging pertinent information among similar facilities within the company or with other companies in the industry group. It also entails cultivating relationships with the communities surrounding the facility and engaging them in safety initiatives. Transparency is integral to this pillar, encouraging the sharing of information about the company and facility’s products, processes, plans, hazards, and risks with both the local communities and authorities.
  4. Measurement and metrics
    The metrics element defines performance and efficiency indicators, enabling the near-real-time monitoring of the effectiveness of the risk-based process safety management system (RBPS), its constituent elements, and associated work activities. This component guides the selection of indicators, determines the frequency of data collection, and outlines actions to be taken based on the information gathered, ensuring a responsive and effective operation of the RBPS management system. 
  5. Management review and continuous improvement
    Management review entails the regular assessment of whether management systems are operating as intended, delivering the desired results efficiently. It represents management’s efforts to monitor the effectiveness of Risk-based management system. This needs an improvement plans or corrective actions as well.

In contrast, the OSHA approach includes an element that is not present in the CCPS approach:

  1. Trade secrets

As defined in OSHA 3132 – Reprinted 2000:

“Employers must make available all information necessary to comply with PSM to those persons responsible for compiling the process safety information, those developing the process hazard analysis, those responsible for developing the operating procedures, and those performing incident investigations, emergency planning and response, and compliance audits, without regard to the possible trade secret status of such information. Nothing in PSM, however, precludes the employer from requiring those persons to enter into confidentiality agreements not to disclose the information.”

The table below provides a quick overview of the distinctions between the two approachs:

ItemCCPS Risk Based approach (20 Elements)OSHA approach (14 Elements)
1Process safety cultureDoesn’t apply
2Compliance with StandardsProcess safety information (PSI)
3Process safety competencyDoesn’t apply
4Workforce involvementEmployee participation
5Stakeholder OutreachDoesn’t apply
6Process knowledge managementProcess safety information (PSI)
7Hazard Identification & Risk AnalysisProcess hazard analysis
8Operating ProceduresOperating Procedures
9Safe Work PracticesOperating Procedures
Hot work permit
10Asset Integrity & ReliabilityMechanical Integrity
11Contractor managementContractors
12Training & Performance AssuranceTraining
13Management of ChangeManagement of Change (MOC)
14Operational ReadinessPre-Startup Safety review
15Conduct of OperationsDoesn’t apply
16Emergency ManagementEmergency Planning and Response
17Incident InvestigationIncident Investigation
18Measurements and MetricsDoesn’t apply
19AuditingCompliance Audits
20Management Review and Continuous ImprovementDoesn’t apply
Doesn’t applyTrade Secrets
CCPS Risk Based approach vs OSHA approach

Implementing and Enhancing PSM

As evident from the preceding section, understanding the geographical location of the plant or company targeted for PSM implementation is crucial. This necessitates familiarity with the applicable requirements, codes, and standards. For a deeper exploration of the variances and hierarchical structure of standards, please refer to this article.

To implement and enhance process safety management, organizations should consider the following steps:

  1. Leadership Commitment: Senior management must demonstrate a strong commitment to process safety, allocate resources, and set a safety culture tone.
  2. Risk Assessment: Conduct thorough risk assessments to identify potential hazards and prioritize risk reduction measures.
  3. Employee Training: Invest in ongoing training and development programs to ensure employees are well-prepared and informed about safety protocols.
  4. Continuous Improvement: Implement a culture of continuous improvement, regularly evaluating and enhancing PSM practices.
  5. Documentation and Reporting: Maintain clear and accessible records of all PSM elements and incidents for reference and compliance purposes.

Conclusion

Process safety management is a critical framework that protects human lives, the environment, and valuable assets in industrial operations. By adhering to the 14 elements and fostering a culture of safety, organizations can mitigate risks and minimize the potential for accidents and incidents. Implementing and enhancing PSM is not just a regulatory requirement but a moral and financial imperative, ensuring that industries operate safely and responsibly. It is a commitment to safety that should be at the core of every industrial organization’s mission.

Contact us

For more information, help on your PSM system or even a tailor-made training for you or your organization please don’t hesitate to contact us!

Please share this content.

Read More